Right after I became a Mrs., I packed up all my new kitchen gadgets and fine china and moved into a 450 sq. ft. studio in the middle of Manhattan with my brand spanking new husband. It was quite the newlywed adventure. I’m actually shocked that we didn’t kill each other in the first 4 months of marriage, considering the only place in the apartment where we couldn’t physically see each other was the bathroom. I tried to love our NYC adventure, but after living in Chicago for the past 3 years, the Big Apple just didn’t stack up. Visiting NYC is one thing, but when I lived there, the fabulous shopping and bustling of the city lost it’s magic and I just couldn’t get past the garbage piles (Thank you Jesus for alleys in Chicago) and unrelenting city noise heard at all hours. I’m a city girl, but clearly not a New York City girl. Thankfully four months later we moved back to Chicago, where our living space more than quadrupled (for the same amount in rent as our NYC one room palace), and I haven’t missed NYC since.
Well, that’s kinda a lie…I did miss two things about NYC and two things only: 1.) Pinkberry, and 2.) A slice of Banana Cake from Billy’s Bakery in Chelsea. And as of today, those two things aren’t really missed anymore because I’ve found acceptable Chicago replacements…and those replacements don’t involve smelly garbage piles or cabs honking outside my bedroom window at 4am, so they might even be better than the originals. My Pinkberry fix was an easy cure when a Berry Chill shop opened up 2 blocks from my office in Chicago. I even have my own Berry Chill companion at work….and we may or may not have enjoyed our favorite frozen treat in the middle of February…in 30 degree weather.
Now, the Banana Cake fix was much harder to satisfy. It’s not a popular cake flavor, so I’ve only found a couple Chicago bakeries that carry it and I have yet to be impressed. Most were dry and lacking in bananananaey flavor. Plus, I have an extremely picky palate when it comes to Cream Cheese Frosting, so I just didn’t think my own recipe could be beat. Then it dawned on me…forget the bakeries, make your own stinking Banana Cake! I did a lot of research…scouring cookbooks, online recipe sites, and baking forums to combine the best practices of Banana Cake making and baking….and in the end, I’m pretty sure my Banana Cake puts Billy’s to shame. The baking method sure is strange and I was skeptical, but the result was one of the moistest, most flavorful cakes I’ve ever made. And the masses agree…I thought Banana Cake luvahs were few and far between so I wasn’t sure how this cake would go over with my ravenous co-workers. Well, it was devoured in record time compared to previous baked goods that I’ve brought in, so I think I’ll be keeping this one in the rotation. Looking back, I guess I’ll always have to be somewhat thankful for garbage piles, sirens at 4am, and 450 sq. ft apartments because without them, I wouldn’t have fallen in love with Banana Cake and made an even better one in my quiet, clean, spacious Chicago home.
P.S. – This recipe works great as both layer cakes and cupcakes…don’t worry, I conducted my own thorough taste tests on both so I could report back to you with the results. It’s tough work being a food blogger.






Banana Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
Cake Batter:
- 2 cups Mashed Bananas (the browner, the better!)
- 1/2 tsp. Cinnamon
- 1/4 tsp. Nutmeg
- 3 cups All Purpose Flour
- 1 1/2 tsp. Baking Soda
- 1/4 tsp. Salt
- 1 1/8 cup White Sugar
- 1 cup Light Brown Sugar
- 3/4 cup Butter, softened
- 1/4 cup Vegetable Oil
- 3 eggs
- 1 tbsp. Vanilla
- 1 1/2 cups Buttermilk
- 1/2 cup Sour Cream
Cream Cheese frosting:
- 1 1/2 pounds Cream Cheese, room temperature
- 1 pound Butter, room temperature
- 2 pounds Powdered Sugar, sifted
- 1 tbsp. Vanilla Extract
- Preheat the oven to 275 degrees. (I know it’s low, but trust me here!) Grease and flour two 9-inch pans or line cupcake pans with liners. (or if you’re me, make both a 3 layer cake AND cupcakes)
- In a small bowl, mash the bananas and add the cinnamon and nutmeg. Stir to combine and set aside.
- In a medium bowl, sift the flour, baking soda, and salt together. Set aside.
- In a large mixing bowl, cream the butter and white/brown sugar together until light and fluffy. Beat in the eggs one at a time, then add the vanilla and oil.
- Beat in the flour mixture alternately with the buttermilk and sour cream. Fold the banana mixture into the batter, then divide evenly between the pans.
- Bake at 275 for 1 to 1 1/2 hours for 9 inch cakes or 30-40 minutes for cupcakes. Remove from the oven and place directly in the freezer for 45 minutes. (Do you like moist, delicious cake? Then do it.)
- For the cream cheese frosting: Whip the butter and cream cheese together in a mixer fitted with a paddle attachment until creamed. Gradually add powdered sugar to the mixture and scrape down the bowl as needed. Add the vanilla and mix until combined. The frosting can be used right away, or stored in the refrigerator up to a week (very dangerous for frosting addicts like myself). Frost cooled cakes with the cream cheese frosting.